Link to purchase from Amazon
Title: Everything, Everything
Author: Nicola Yoon
Publisher: Delacorte Press, Hardcover 335 pages
Publication Date: September 1, 2015
Genre: Teen and Young Adult, Contemporary Fiction
Let me preface this by saying that the following makes a little more sense if you've already read my review of THE SUN IS ALSO A STAR.
THINGS THAT I LIKED:
- Nicola Yoon is still a pretty good author. I don't like the stories that she tells, but I can't say that she doesn't tell them well. As I said in my previous review of her work, I desperately want to enjoy Yoon, but she doesn't make it easy.
- This is another fun(ish) and very quick read.
THINGS THAT I DID NOT LIKE:
- This story is just too silly. You want to like it, because the characters are struggling and you want them to win... but it's impossible.
- Teenage sex is a no-no; in reality it happens, I know, but to tell a story where two teenagers end up running off to Hawaii to enjoy what is essentially a honeymoon together... come on, now. It isn't realistic, and to spuriously glamorize it makes me feel so uncomfortable. You can tell the story just as well without the fornication, so why include it? It's like excessive swearing (which this book did not include, by the way)-profanity is acceptable and there is a time and place for it, but to validate the overactive potty-mouth just seems irresponsible. I don't mean to be a stick in the mud, but I also don't care if that's how you view my opinion on the matter; I want to support literature that pushes the reader and challenges the minds of all who consume it. Sinking to the level of "sex sells" assumes that your reader has limited self-respect and is not completely in touch with the realistic side of society.
- Without giving away the actual ending, let me say that I did not really appreciate it. There was a "twist" that was pretty good, but then the last chapter takes it a little too far (for me).
- There are quite a few more, but I honestly don't want to waste any more time than I need to on this book.
Once again, Yoon has me all uptight. I was hoping this book would be as good as other reviews that I've read on it, but it was a pretty colossal disappointment. The one good thing was that this was an insanely quick read (as in literally a couple of hours), so I didn't waste a lot of time on it and it was, admittedly, a nice break from some of the heavier stuff I've currently got my nose stuffed in. I had a lot of thoughts that I don't even feel like organizing... I'd rather just close the book and allow it to serve a higher purpose of dust collection. But without going into a lot of detail, I did want to share a few reasons I didn't like this book/improvements I would've made:
Please don't underestimate your reader. I know that I am not technically included in the target audience on this one, but I usually read books with the intention of sharing them with others who might enjoy them... I can't do that if you have no respect for your audience. I have read many a children's book (JACK) that I have found both thought provoking and also age appropriate, so let's be fair and acknowledge that it is completely possible to write a relevant story without exploiting your audience's "weak spot", so to speak. Please assume that we can follow complex thought processes (which I believe this author is capable of producing!), that we can keep up with your use of challenging vocabulary words (either by knowing them or being willing to learn them), and that we can enjoy entertainment that isn't littered with sex, drugs, profanity, etc. Some authors can't rise to the occasion, and neither can some readers... but when there's potential to be great, please don't sell us all short.
So... NO, I won't be recommending this one. Frankly, there are so many other young adult novels that have a lot to offer, and this one really has nothing I'd care to endorse**. I can find basically no redeeming factors, EXCEPT that I do still enjoy Yoon's writing style... and that's just a personal preference, not something that I'd guess other people would likely relate to.
I wish that this review were a little more cohesive, but I really didn't even want to write it. Sorrynotsorry!
**I don't have that high of an opinion of myself that I assume that people care about my thoughts on anything, but the reality is that I have a lot of friends and coworkers who ask for book recommendations all of the time (this is why I buy most of my books--so that I can easily pass them around). A lot of my coworkers have teenagers that need books/recommendations for various reasons, so I keep up with young adult literature partially for that reason. I also just generally enjoy it...